PCUSA Approves Amendment Mandating LGBT Ideology Questions for Clergy
The Presbyterian Church (USA) has finalized a controversial amendment requiring clergy candidates to answer questions about their views on LGBT ideology. Amendment 24-C, part of the broader Olympia Overture, passed a majority of presbyteries last month and will go into effect on July 4.
New Standards Spark Tensions Within the Denomination
Amendment 24-C modifies section G-2.0104b of the Book of Order, allowing ordaining bodies to examine candidates’ theological stances specifically on sexual orientation and gender identity. A companion amendment, 24-A, which adds those categories to the denomination’s anti-discrimination clause, also passed with strong support.
While 24-A received broad backing for promoting justice and inclusion, Amendment 24-C has ignited pushback from many clergy. Critics argue it places undue scrutiny on personal beliefs and conscience, potentially disqualifying candidates who hold traditional theological views.
Critics Warn of Overreach and Threat to Conscience
Revs. Tony and Katie Sundermeier of First Presbyterian Atlanta joined other clergy in signing an open letter opposing the amendment. They noted their support for 24-A but said 24-C “crosses a line” by enforcing a new form of theological orthodoxy.
“Inclusion loses its moral and spiritual power when it becomes an enforced orthodoxy rather than a gracious welcome,” they said. The couple fears the change enables exclusion based on views still consistent with the denomination’s constitution.
Rev. Ferdi Brits of Presbyterian Church of the Lakes in Florida added that 24-C “removes my freedom of conscience.” He believes disagreement with progressive doctrine could now block leadership opportunities.
Ambiguity and Legal Questions Add to Division
Rev. LaVera M. Parato from North Carolina voiced concern over the amendment’s vague language, warning it may require judicial clarification. She cautioned that the term “discrimination” could be inconsistently applied across ordaining bodies.
These disputes come as PCUSA faces declining membership, which fell from 2.5 million in 2000 to just over 1 million last year. Leaders anticipate dropping below the one-million mark by year’s end, with some linking the trend to the denomination’s progressive positions.
Source:
PCUSA’s New Ordination Standards Raise Concerns Over Control and Exclusion
Photo by James A. Molnar on Unsplash
About Post Author
