The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has proposed a six-year federal funding ban on Catholic Charities of the Rio Grande Valley (CCRGV), citing billing and reporting inconsistencies in the nonprofit’s migrant services. The organization, led by Sister Norma Pimentel—an internationally recognized figure in Catholic humanitarian work—has been central to aiding migrants in Brownsville, Texas. DHS accuses CCRGV of exceeding the federally allowed 45-day service window and of submitting conflicting data on migrant support.
Allegations Spark Controversy and Strong Reactions
In documents shared with Fox News Digital, DHS claims Pimentel misused federal trust and invoked Catholic social teaching to justify its actions. The agency argues that mass migration undermines human dignity and national responsibility, echoing rhetoric used by Vice President JD Vance. But critics say the DHS letter misrepresents Church teachings. Pope Francis, in a 2024 letter to U.S. bishops, warned that deporting migrants strips them of dignity and worsens their vulnerability.
CCRGV responded swiftly, stating that all DHS funding was used for individuals brought to the group by U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The organization has 30 days to respond to the proposed debarment. “We will work expeditiously with DHS to resolve this matter,” CCRGV said.
Broader Religious and Political Implications
Faith leaders see the DHS move as part of a broader pattern. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops flagged “targeting of faith-based immigration services” as a key religious liberty issue earlier this year. Bishop Daniel Flores, a vocal migrant rights advocate and Pimentel’s superior, was recently elected vice president of the USCCB.
Meanwhile, Catholic Charities has faced years of criticism from Republican officials and conservative groups. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sought to depose Pimentel in a migrant shelter probe, and advocacy group CatholicVote previously sued the Biden administration for communications with CCRGV.
Local Impact and Future Uncertainty
CCRGV’s migrant aid is only part of its outreach. The organization also addresses poverty in South Texas, where the Diocese of Brownsville’s 25% poverty rate exceeds the national average. It remains unclear how the funding suspension may affect local services. DHS and the diocese have not responded to inquiries.
Despite growing scrutiny, Pimentel remains firm. “Those on the front lines of our humanitarian outreach know the work we do truly helps to restore human dignity,” she said.
Source:
DHS threatens Sister Norma Pimentel’s migrant aid with 6-year funding ban
Photo by Barbara Zandoval on Unsplash
About Post Author
