A federal judge has partially granted a temporary restraining order in a legal battle between the Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and Chaplaincy (JAFC) and the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA). The case stems from JAFC’s attempt to formally disaffiliate from ACNA, a move the denomination has refused to acknowledge. The legal dispute raises key concerns over religious autonomy and trademark rights.
Judge Rules on Trademark Use Amid Ecclesiastical Dispute
U.S. District Judge Bruce Hendricks issued the partial order in South Carolina last week. While declining to intervene in the broader ecclesiastical conflict, Hendricks found JAFC’s trademark claims compelling. The judge noted that ACNA’s legal counsel conceded the church would cease using JAFC’s service mark, “Jurisdiction of the Armed Forces and Chaplaincy,” the trademark “Anglican Chaplains,” and the ministry’s logo.
Citing sufficient evidence, Hendricks granted JAFC’s request for a preliminary injunction on those three items. However, he emphasized the court’s intention to avoid entanglement in internal church governance, signaling judicial limits in ecclesiastical disputes.
Slander Allegations Denied Due to Lack of Evidence
JAFC also sought legal protection from alleged slander by ACNA officials, particularly Bishop Derek Jones. Judge Hendricks declined this request, citing vague evidence and unresolved factual disputes. He emphasized that existing laws already provide remedies for defamation and declined to issue a separate order.
The court also noted multiple material disagreements between the parties that cannot be resolved without further proceedings.
Denominational Rift Deepens Over Chaplaincy Control
The dispute began when JAFC sent a letter in September announcing its decision to leave ACNA. The denomination rejected the move and instead appointed new leaders over the chaplaincy. In response, JAFC filed its federal complaint last month, asserting control over its name, logo, and organizational identity.
Supporters of JAFC argue the ministry must protect its independence and branding. Critics within ACNA claim the group is attempting to bypass the authority and governance structures of the church.
Source:
Judge Partly Grants Restraining Order in Dispute Between ACNA and Military Chaplains Jurisdiction
Photo by Erik Mclean on Unsplash
About Post Author
