__CONFIG_widget_menu__{"menu_id":"866","dropdown_icon":"style_1","mobile_icon":"style_1","dir":"tve_horizontal","icon":{"top":"","sub":""},"layout":{"default":"grid"},"type":"regular","mega_desc":"e30=","images":[],"logo":false,"responsive_attributes":{"top":{"desktop":"text","tablet":"","mobile":""},"sub":{"desktop":"text","tablet":"","mobile":""}},"actions":[],"uuid":"m-181b8bae428","template":"39777","template_name":"Dropdown 01","unlinked":{".menu-item-16075":false,".menu-item-16081":false,".menu-item-16080":false,".menu-item-16079":false,".menu-item-16078":false,".menu-item-16077":false},"top_cls":{".menu-item-16075":"",".menu-item-16077":"","main":"",".menu-item-16081":"",".menu-item-16080":""},"tve_tpl_menu_meta":{"menu_layout_type":"Horizontal"},"tve_shortcode_rendered":1}__CONFIG_widget_menu__

Highland Park Methodist Church Split Sparks New Legal Fight in Dallas

Highland Park Methodist Church has intensified its legal dispute with the United Methodist Church (UMC), seeking a temporary restraining order over the congregation’s name. The prominent Dallas church filed court documents November 10, arguing that the denomination’s continued use of Highland Park United Methodist Church violates its trademarks. The dispute follows an October vote in which members of the 110-year-old congregation overwhelmingly supported leaving the denomination. Approximately 90% of the nearly 5,000 participating members voted to separate, although UMC rules contain no provision permitting such a departure. The congregation wants to operate independently as Highland Park Methodist Church while preventing the denomination from establishing another congregation under its former name.

Bishop Establishes Congregation for Members Remaining With UMC

Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr., who leads the Horizon Texas Conference, responded to the departure vote by organizing a congregation for members wishing to remain United Methodist. Approximately 10% of participating members voted against leaving, and Saenz appointed the Rev. Andy Lewis to lead their continuing congregation. The group now worships at Southern Methodist University’s Prothro Great Hall under the name Highland Park United Methodist Church. Conference leaders maintain that members should freely choose their denominational affiliation and worship community. Meanwhile, the departing congregation argues that another church using its historic name would create confusion and violate its legally protected identity. Former President George W. Bush and former first lady Laura Bush were among those who supported leaving the denomination.

Church Governance and Property Dispute Remains Unresolved

The Highland Park Methodist Church dispute began in August when Saenz sued the congregation over changes to its governing documents. Church leaders had removed “United” from the organization’s legal name and transferred broader decision-making authority to its church council. Those changes challenged governance responsibilities traditionally exercised by the denomination. Supporters of the departure seek congregational independence and protection of the church’s established identity. The conference, however, maintains its responsibility to serve members who remain United Methodist. The original lawsuit concerning church governance and property remains unresolved, while the new trademark dispute adds another legal conflict between the congregation and denominational leadership.


Source: Dallas’ Highland Park church sues the UMC over rights to its name
Photo by Daniel McCullough on Unsplash

About Post Author


Related Daily News

>