Legal Group Claims Assembly Violated Constitution
A recent elementary school performance in Davidson County, North Carolina, is under fire after a Christian music group sang during school hours. Americans United for Separation of Church and State sent letters of complaint to both Davidson County Schools and the 3 Heath Brothers, alleging a breach of the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. The group claims the March assembly at Hasty Elementary School featured explicitly Christian content.
Advocacy Group Demands Policy Changes
Ian Smith, staff attorney for Americans United, described the event as a “flagrant violation” of constitutional protections. He called for assurances that religious assemblies would not recur and that staff be trained on legal boundaries. The organization says the concert violated families’ religious freedom and cited evidence, including photos of allegedly religious materials handed to students.
3 Heath Brothers Deny Proselytizing
The 3 Heath Brothers, a Christian band managed by Jonathan Heath, rejected the allegations. Heath stated the school performance was not religious in nature and emphasized the group tailors its message for public schools. “We try to be careful… not to be proselytizing,” Heath told The Christian Post. He also said the band performs both in secular and Christian settings.
School District Stands by Assembly’s Purpose
Davidson County Schools Superintendent Greggory Slate defended the assembly, noting it focused on anti-bullying and positive messaging. Slate said faith-based groups are allowed under specific guidelines, including non-proselytization and content vetting. “As long as performers meet policy and legal precedent, DCS can support a performance,” Slate stated.
Community Divided Over Event’s Intent
Supporters argue the group brought a positive, hopeful message to students, with Jonathan Heath citing rising youth suicide rates as a reason for outreach. Critics, however, remain concerned about potential religious indoctrination. Americans United reports the band may have misrepresented their assembly’s content and is awaiting a formal response.
Source:
NC school under fire for hosting ‘Christian boyband’ performance
Photo by Austin Neill on Unsplash
About Post Author
