Controversial Honor Sparks Catholic Outcry
Cardinal Blase Cupich of the Archdiocese of Chicago is under fire for plans to honor Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) with a Lifetime Achievement Award. Durbin is set to be recognized at the Keep Hope Alive immigration benefit on November 3, hosted by the archdiocese’s Office of Human Dignity and Solidarity. Critics argue the award contradicts Catholic doctrine, given Durbin’s long-standing pro-abortion record.
Bishop Paprocki Warns of Public Confusion
Bishop Thomas Paprocki of Durbin’s home diocese in Springfield issued a sharp rebuke, warning the honor could cause “grave scandal.” He noted Durbin’s consistent support for abortion, including opposition to laws protecting babies who survive failed abortions. Paprocki emphasized that honoring a politician who publicly opposes Catholic moral principles undermines Church teaching and confuses the faithful.
Award Violates Archdiocese Policy, Critics Say
Paprocki also cited an official archdiocesan policy, which prohibits awards or honors for individuals who publicly oppose Catholic moral teachings. He urged Cardinal Cupich to reverse the decision “for the sake of clarity, unity and fidelity to the gospel of life.” Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone of San Francisco echoed those concerns, saying the move puts both “clarity and unity” at risk.
Cupich Stands Firm, Cites Broader Catholic Values
Cardinal Cupich responded by defending the decision as consistent with Vatican guidance that encourages dialogue with Catholic politicians. He argued that Catholic social teaching encompasses more than a single issue. Citing Durbin’s immigration advocacy and support for the environment, Cupich framed the award as a reflection of the Church’s commitment to all aspects of human dignity.
Tensions Reflect Broader Church Struggles
Durbin, who has been barred from communion in Springfield since 2004, maintains a 0% rating from the National Right to Life Committee. The controversy reignites long-standing debates within the Catholic Church over how to engage with pro-abortion Catholic politicians. Cupich’s decision appears final, despite increasing criticism from other Church leaders.
Source:
Photo by Sawyer Bengtson on Unsplash
About Post Author
