Recent years have seen a rise in media and academic critiques claiming religion—especially evangelical Christianity—harms women and families. These critiques often spotlight domestic violence, asking whether faith enables abuse. A high-profile example is the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s report, “Submit to Your Husbands,” which alleged churches in Australia concealed abuse and pressured women to remain in violent marriages. Critics argued that traditional teachings on male authority may fuel abuse. Supporters of evangelical communities, however, contend these portrayals misrepresent most believers’ experiences and motivations.
Evidence Shows Churchgoing Evangelical Men Are Least Likely to Be Abusive
Contrary to alarming headlines, social science research paints a more nuanced picture. Studies indicate that men who attend church regularly, especially evangelical Protestants, are the least likely to abuse their wives. In national surveys, churchgoing evangelical men report high levels of affection, understanding, and couple time. Their wives also report greater happiness compared to other groups. Regular church attendance correlates with lower domestic violence rates, with frequent attenders 72% less likely to be violent.
Nominal Christians Show Higher Risk of Spousal Abuse
While committed religious practice appears protective, nominal Christian men—those who identify with the faith but rarely attend services—display higher levels of abuse. Researchers suggest cultural or regional factors may play a role. These men may also misuse religious teachings on male authority. Mixed-faith marriages involving conservative men and less religious women also show greater risk, indicating that shared religious commitment may be key to healthy relationships.
Extrinsic Religion and Church Silence Remain Areas of Concern
Studies also show men who practice religion for external reasons, like social approval, may be more abusive. Although this evidence is limited, it suggests that authentic belief matters. Meanwhile, critics argue churches need to do more to confront domestic violence. While not widespread, some clergy avoid the topic to preserve marriages, inadvertently allowing abuse to continue. Reformers within the faith community are urging pastors and counselors to speak out more forcefully against violence.
Religion’s Broader Positive Influence on Marriage
Overall, research suggests that regular religious participation strengthens marriages. Supportive church networks, shared values, and spiritual practices like praying together contribute to marital stability. Faith appears to buffer couples from external stress and reinforce commitment. For evangelicals and other religious Americans, these factors often outweigh concerns about gender roles. Data shows that beliefs in marital permanence—not traditional gender norms—best predict wives’ happiness in Christian marriages.
Source:
Evangelicals and Domestic Violence: Are Christian Men More Abusive?
Photo by Tuong Nguyen on Unsplash
About Post Author
