The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has elected Archbishop Paul Coakley of Oklahoma City as its new president. The decision marks a continuation of the body’s conservative trajectory during a politically volatile time. Coakley, a known conservative voice, will serve a three-year term, succeeding Archbishop Timothy Broglio. His election signals an endorsement of stronger culture war stances, particularly on abortion and LGBTQ+ rights, while maintaining vocal support for migrant rights.
Conservative Leadership Chosen in Divided Field
Coakley emerged victorious after three rounds of voting, defeating Bishop Daniel Flores of Brownsville, Texas—a centrist and strong Vatican ally. Flores, elected vice president, is respected for his advocacy on immigration issues and his leadership in the church’s synod process. Coakley previously served as the bishops’ secretary and advises the Napa Institute, a hub for conservative Catholic leaders. His support for excommunicated Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò has raised concerns about his alignment with divisive church figures.
Tensions With the Vatican Likely to Grow
Observers note the selection may heighten tensions with Pope Leo XIV, who has followed Pope Francis’ inclusive approach. The Vatican’s pastoral emphasis on marginalized communities contrasts with Coakley’s prioritization of doctrinal orthodoxy. “This is not a de-escalating step,” warned theologian Steven Millies, highlighting ongoing friction between U.S. bishops and Rome. Despite similar teachings on core issues, Coakley’s style is seen as more of a culture-war approach, while Flores is perceived as more conciliatory.
Immigration Stance Offers Common Ground
Despite ideological differences, the bishops remain united in advocating for the rights of immigrants. During their annual meeting, they worked on a statement addressing harsh U.S. immigration enforcement. Fear among undocumented Catholics has led to reduced Mass attendance, while clerics report challenges in administering sacraments in detention centers. Bishop Kevin Rhoades emphasized worship as a fundamental right, regardless of legal status, a position echoed in a letter the bishops sent to Pope Leo.
Supporters and Critics React to Coakley’s Election
Supporters hail Coakley as a principled leader who will defend traditional Catholic values. Critics fear his approach may further alienate marginalized groups and deepen rifts with the Vatican. Some worry this direction risks sidelining broader pastoral priorities in favor of ideological battles. Others, however, see hope in Flores’ vice presidency, suggesting the conference may yet pivot toward unity and engagement with Rome in future elections.
Source:
US Catholic bishops select conservative culture warrior to lead them during Trump’s second term
Photo by Brandon Morgan on Unsplash
About Post Author
