An honorary doctorate for Hasia Diner became a defining moment at the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College’s commencement on May 17. The ceremony drew attention because Hasia Diner renounced Zionism a decade ago, and many Jewish institutions long kept her at arm’s length. Yet the college said it recognized scholarly achievement, not ideology, and it pointed to her influence on American Jewish history.
A Scholar Once Shunned, Now Recognized
Diner, 79, has written 11 books on the American Jewish experience. She has examined immigration, women’s history, Black-Jewish relations, peddling, and foodways. She built her career at New York University, and she kept publishing even as invitations vanished. Former students describe her work as rigorous, and they say she pairs careful research with moral clarity.
The Op-Ed That Drew a Line
In 2015, Diner spoke quietly with historian Marjorie Feld about growing alienation from Zionism. They decided to write publicly, so they co-authored a Haaretz essay rejecting the label. Diner described being asked to join the World Zionist Congress but needing to affirm “strengthening” Israel as a Jewish, Zionist, democratic state. That requirement pushed her to break, because she opposed a state granting one group superior status.
Blowback, Blacklists, and a New Climate
The backlash arrived fast. Diner received a flood of messages, and some became threatening. Speaking invitations disappeared, and she learned her name sat on lists that made hosts retreat. Still, she later contributed essays to Evolve, tied to the Reconstructionist movement. She also said the honorary doctorate would have seemed unlikely five years ago, but it no longer felt shocking.
Two Commencements, Two Signals
The contrast sharpened with the Jewish Theological Seminary’s decision to honor Israeli President Isaac Herzog. Students protested, and the plan signaled a firm Zionist stance. Supporters of Diner saw her honorary doctorate as overdue recognition of American Jewish history told without nostalgia, and they welcomed a Diaspora-centered Judaism. Detractors viewed her renunciation of Zionism as disloyal, and they worried that such honors would normalize anti-Zionism in communal life.
She was shunned for renouncing Zionism. A decade later, a rabbinical college is honoring her.
About Post Author
