Dispute Over Church Authority Escalates
David Zima, a former ruling elder at St. Andrew’s Chapel in Sanford, Florida, is locked in a growing conflict with his former church. After the church’s controversial decision to leave the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) in late 2024, Zima resigned and sought membership at another PCA congregation. But St. Andrew’s elders refuse to release him, accusing him of “contumacy” and pursuing discipline despite his departure.
New Church Rejects Charges, Supports Zima
Northside Presbyterian Church in Melbourne has accepted Zima as a member in good standing and dismissed the charges from St. Andrew’s as baseless. The elders warned St. Andrew’s not to interfere, citing both Presbyterian polity and religious freedom. They assert St. Andrew’s no longer has jurisdiction over Zima, who is no longer part of their church or denomination.
Critics Call It Retaliation, Not Accountability
Former members and critics see the disciplinary action as retaliatory. They believe Zima is being punished for aiding members with concerns about Pastor Burk Parsons. “They want a scapegoat,” said George Knevelbaard, a former congregant. Others, including a PCA polity expert, said the church’s process appears rushed and lacking due process. Bob Mattes, Zima’s defense counsel, said the case is one of the weakest he has encountered in 40 years.
Church Leaders Stand Firm Despite Legal Risks
Despite growing criticism, St. Andrew’s elders maintain they have the authority to discipline Zima. In a January 28 letter, they insisted their process is valid and constitutionally protected. They argue that resignation does not exempt a member from church discipline. However, legal precedent and PCA rules suggest otherwise, and further legal conflict may be imminent.
Zima Seeks Closure, Still Hopes for Reconciliation
Zima, once a close advisor to Parsons, now feels spiritually “imprisoned.” Though deeply hurt, he says he still loves Parsons and hopes for reconciliation. But for now, he simply wants the church to release him. “I deny your jurisdiction,” he wrote, asking St. Andrew’s to stop pursuing him and respect his decision to leave.
Source:
Burk Parsons’ Florida church won’t allow elder to resign
Photo by K Adams on Unsplash
About Post Author
