A Bold Turn Toward Spiritual Themes
Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery marks a thematic shift in Rian Johnson’s mystery trilogy. Departing from the satirical tone of Knives Out and Glass Onion, the new film dives deep into questions of Christian faith, spiritual warfare, and personal belief. Johnson, once a devout Christian, draws on his evangelical upbringing to craft a story as much about salvation and skepticism as murder and motive. The film challenges genre expectations and invites audiences to engage with deeper philosophical and spiritual questions beneath the surface of a whodunit.
A Murder in the Church, and a Detective Without Faith
The film follows Father Jud (Josh O’Connor), a former boxer with a violent past, now assigned to assist the incendiary Monsignor Wicks (Josh Brolin) at a Catholic parish. When Wicks is murdered on Good Friday, Jud becomes the prime suspect. Detective Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig), a self-described heretic, arrives to solve the case. But the heart of the story lies in Jud and Blanc’s uneasy alliance—each representing opposing poles of belief and doubt.
Rian Johnson’s Personal Conflict on Screen
Johnson describes the writing process as therapeutic. He channeled both the mercy-driven faith of Jud and the fear-fueled ideology of Wicks from his own church experiences. Catholicism, rather than Protestantism, gave him narrative distance while allowing him to examine spiritual power struggles with honesty. Though he now identifies as nonreligious, Johnson admits the film’s creation reconnected him with deeply held values. Writing from both belief and skepticism, Johnson revisits his inner spiritual conflict through character dialogue and dramatic confrontation.
Tension Between Belief Systems
The characters debate the purpose of faith throughout the film. Jud sees beauty and truth in spiritual stories. Blanc, shaped by trauma and hypocrisy, considers religion as a manipulative force. Their evolving relationship creates emotional depth, but Johnson resists easy conclusions. “Blanc doesn’t have a conversion,” he insists. The film offers no final answers—only more questions.
A Divisive but Thoughtful Mystery
Supporters praise Wake Up Dead Man for exploring faith without preaching, while critics argue the film risks alienating both believers and skeptics. Still, Johnson’s approach—blending genre thrills with spiritual reflection—may resonate with audiences willing to wrestle with moral ambiguity. The film adds emotional complexity to the franchise, pushing boundaries of both genre and personal storytelling.
Source:
Rian Johnson on miracles, mystery and his own faith story in ‘Wake Up Dead Man’
Photo by Felix Mooneeram on Unsplash
About Post Author
