Why Christians Must Reject Fear and Hatred of Muslims

Jesus was not silent about his enemies, consisting primarily of religious hypocrites. His other targets were political foes who tried to harm him to meet their political ends. Even so, he spent considerably more time in his ministry talking about love. For those focused on warfare with their enemies, one has to wonder if they have read these well-established accounts latelyโ€”Matthew, Mark, Luke, and Johnโ€”without filtering them through their preferred political lenses.

Openly Hating One’s Neighbors

I have been trying to reason with my immigrant-hating friends for several years now. Sadly, my history with them has prepared me to expect bad behavior. Most of the self-labeled conservatives with whom I sometimes minister should have known better. The first alarming message to catch my attention during the mid-term election season was one posted by a man whom I know to be culturally evangelical. It was a picture of a friendly-looking, brown-skinned family dressed in South Asian or Middle Eastern garb. The caption demanded to know if YOU would call ICE to investigate this family if they lived next door to you. I have been feeling obligated to respond to the racism I have encountered during this era, particularly when acquaintances propagate it. My connection with the man posting is that I had been required to hold some conferences with him regarding the mental health and substance abuse treatment for one of his family members. So, I responded to his social media post with, “Of course notโ€”why would I suspect these were immigrants who had overstayed their visas? Because of the way they dress? And even if their green cards HAD expired, how neighborly is it to harass people who are living peacefully next door to you?” I also posted several Scripture portions, noting how the Torah admonished the Israelite nation to welcome the stranger. I might have referenced the Sheep and the Goats parable. I probably also made a passing reference to entertaining angels unawares.

It then became apparent to me that this man had not expected dialogueโ€”he had simply assumed everyone would agree with him, since his closest friends likely held similarly ethnocentric views. The man was enraged by my response, utilizing words I had no idea he was in the habit of employing. I honestly don’t think he realized who I was when he posted his vitriolic remarks; it wasn’t as if we had been corresponding weekly. Fortunately, another poster challenged him as well, and he stopped responding, but without an apology, and without removing the content from his wall. After that, I noted that he began posting nothing but scripture references for several consecutive days. Apparently, he felt the need to re-establish with his audience the notion that he was a God-fearing man who believed in the Scriptures– selective Scriptures, anywayโ€”since that Jesus-stuff did not seem to resonate with him very profoundly.

Searching for the Worst in Others

The next questioner I challenged would not let it go. “But YOU don’t understand Islam at all,” he retorted after I had challenged his bigotry. I explained to him that I had taken five graduate-level classes in Islam, including one with a prominent scholar from Fuller Seminary who had written extensively on outreach to Muslims. “Well then how could you seriously not know (about all the evils of Islam) after taking so many classes on it? Oh wait, I think I figured it out. A lot of Western professors want to make excuses for Islam and hide what it actually teaches and what Muhammad actually did. They teach Islam with rose-tinted glasses, which explains why you’ve never heard of this stuff,” he continued. Otherwise, I would not be so naive about their threats to Americans and about their official treatment of unbelievers. “If you love Jesus, you would hate Islam,” he concluded. I explained to him that I’d had several instructors and, yes, one of them had been somewhat of a Christian Nationalist, echoing many of my friend’s sentiments. I had taken most of my Master’s-level classes at Pat Robertson’s Regent University, after all. It had not exactly been a hotbed of progressive, pro-jihadist theology.

Fortunately, not all my former instructors had promoted similarly reactionary attitudes. Years after I graduated, I took what was possibly the most inspiring class I can recall at the same seminary, entitled “Philosophy of Religion.” In that one, we learned to respect various wisdom traditions, recognizing that we can’t expect others to take our claims about Christ seriously if we don’t also thoughtfully consider their worldviews. Yes, this further fostered empathy in me for other faiths, particularly the Abrahamic religions. I had been preparing for missionary service to Bangladesh, and how did I expect to reach Muslims if I made a mockery of the things most sacred to them?

The Limits of Apologetics in a Biblical Worldview

My friend assured me that, despite not having any Christian education whatsoever at the post-high-school level, he knew far more than I about Islam. He knew all the passages in which Muhammad wished ill on unbelievers; and yes, those are authentic passages, although I have no idea how well they survived translation from Arabic to English. But my friend was admittedly learning all this from self-study (often internet videos) in Apologetics. What he did not realize, in his two and a half years as a believer, was that he was subjecting himself to polemical discourse calculated to win arguments. Apologetics rarely helps people foster strong friendships. It is not typically an evangelistic tool, but it can certainly make a person feel more confident, or even smug, about their own beliefs.

Violent Treatment of Enemies in the Old Testament

In the Old Testament, YHWH commanded the Israelite army to enact herem (total destruction) on the inhabitants of various Canaanite cities. Deuteronomy 7 reveals one of several examples:

When the Lord your God brings you into the land you are entering to possess and drives out before you many nationsโ€”the Hittites, Girgashites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites, seven nations larger and stronger than youโ€”and when the Lord your God has delivered them over to you and you have defeated them, then you must destroy them totally. Make no treaty with them, and show them no mercy.  (Deuteronomy 7:1-2)

He also instructed King Saul to obliterate the Amalekites (“Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.”, I Samuel 15:3). When Saul neglected to do so, the text also declares that God regretted that he had ever made Saul the king over Israel (I Samuel 15:35).

King David romanticized the notion of taking his enemies’ babies and smashing their skulls upon the rocks:

Daughter Babylon, doomed to destruction,
    happy is the one who repays you
    according to what you have done to us.
 Happy is the one who seizes your infants
    and dashes them against the rocks.  -Psalm 137:8-9

Understanding Context in Historic Literature

Butโ€ฆ but, you may say. There is more to know about these Scriptures. One has to understand the context. You must understand the situations the Israelites were facing in their era. You must recognize how God’s People had to preserve themselves from destructionโ€ฆ

I’m a stickler for context. I understand a good deal about Old Testament hermeneutics. Do my Muslim-hating evangelical friends expect to persuade me that there are NO textual issues worthy of consideration in the Quranic passages they are quoting? None of the citizens offering their arguments to me are scholars of Islam. They barely understand the Torah, particularly because all of them wish to place the Ten Commandments on the walls of our courthouses and schools. And they surmise that the Ten Commandments are allegedly binding uponโ€”who, the church of Jesus Christ? Do the ones brokering these rationalizations wish to persuade me they are a bunch of Sabbath-keepers? That they never use the Lord’s name vainly, even though I hear them misrepresenting the Gospels regularly?

When Religion Becomes Political

You see, it’s easy to recognize how a political Islam exists. Middle Eastern countries, and some Asian and African countries, find it convenient to use religion as a means of keeping their citizens in line. Do these dialogue partners of mine think there is, correspondingly, NO political Christianity? The latter has been fairly well documented since at least the early fourth century, when just before the battle of the Milvian Bridge, Emperor Constantine thought he received divine inspiration by seeing the sign of the cross in the sky with a corresponding message: “In this sign conquer.” He immediately began promoting his version of the faith, and Christianity became a political religion for many centuriesโ€”which some would say has endured to the present day. State churches are still the norm in many European nations, and it’s hardly a secret that this church-and-state phenomenon has been replicated, to varying degrees, in Luther’s Germany and Calvin’s Switzerland. When the colonies were born early in American history, the dominant church in each village often dictated community life, with severe penalties for those who deviated.

Contemporary and Historic Church/State Issues

And what about todayโ€”aren’t the Christian Nationalists calling for the abolition of Islam in the USA also lobbying for Christianity to be recognized as the official religion of the USA? In other words, they seem completely in favor of ignoring the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. As I was writing this article, another friend posted about how we are citizens of a Christian nation that needs protecting from heathen influences, especially Islam. Many of my friends seem to be more enthusiastic about political religion here at home than the Ayatollah is about his variety of political Islam practiced in Iran. My well-meaning friends seem to have forgotten their history studies and this little conflict in the Middle Ages called “The Crusades,” which lasted nearly two hundred years. These military campaigns originated with Pope Urban II, who encouraged political “Christians” to arm themselves against political Muslims to “take back territory for the church.” These armed conflicts were hardly the actions of people who were following the lead of the same Messiah who proclaimed that we should love our neighbors as much as ourselves.

Islam is Growing in America

Dearborn, Michigan, is the most Islamicized large city in our nation, with a Muslim population of about 40-45%. Nearby Hamtramck, Michigan, is the only city with over fifty percent of residents identifying as Muslims. Because of this one anomaly, panic has set in. “Do you really think that Islam is not going to begin growing and taking over other cities?” I am asked. Actually, I am thoroughly convinced that other cities may easily reach that fifty-plus percent threshold of Muslims in this century. That is consistent with the general demographic shift in the U.S.  I also believe there will be several cities that will soon have a majority population professing to be “nones”, or non-religious people. Are you panicking yet?

Violent and Deviant Movements in “Christian” America

I also see “Christian” groups such as the Westboro Baptist Church hitting the streets of America, promoting hatred and heresy. Militia groups identified with the “Christian Identity” movement are gaining prominence and may begin dominating politics in the towns where they are located. I remember a “Christian” group called the Branch Davidians becoming enmeshed in some unsavory activities, including pedophilia and the stockpiling of arms. *  I also remember a couple of white guys embracing sentiments akin to Christian Nationalism who blew up the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City, killing 168 people, including toddlers; Initially, this heinous crime was assumed to be the work of Islamic terrorists. I even remember a “Christian” group in Guyana that was co-opted into a murder-suicide pact, killing over nine hundred women, children and men.

Then again, if my Muslim-fearing evangelical friends are genuinely concerned about historic pedophilia, polygamy and extreme heresies, why begin with the Dearborn, Michigan area? Have they not heard that the largest city in Utah is also politically dominated by people with extrabiblical beliefs? In fact, Mormon influence dominates the entire state, as well as other cities in nearby states. Like Muhammad, the founder of Mormonism also had a penchant for assault, battery and pursuing young girls. Has the panic set in yet?

Panic Regarding Sharia Law

Fears I’ve heard expressed about America coming under Sharia Law are so ridiculous that I hate even to mention itโ€”but this is what my selective relatives and friends seem most worried about. Amending even one sentence of our Constitution would require approval from 75% of our states and a supermajority of Congress. The Equal Rights Amendment could not meet that high bar after ten years of lobbying, so it never became law. The last time the Constitution was amended was in 1992, over congressional salaries. But now, in 2026, Michigan has elected one professing Muslim senator who will be sworn in next year. There is one Muslim-dominated town in America, a Muslim mayor in New York City, a handful of Muslim congresspeople andโ€ฆ it’s apparently time to panic! Although no American has demonstrated acumen for amending even a minor clause to the Constitution, the fearmongers would have us to believe that in just a few years, these powerful politicians will throw out our entire founding documents, and our entire nation will embrace Sharia Law with thirty-eight states ratifying it, and sixty-seven percent of Congress going along. Just how persuasive must these Muslims be to accomplish such a feat?

Islam is Not a Gospel-Centered Faith

Lest I be misunderstood, I am not ambivalent about Islamic doctrine. I believe it is erroneous, as I also believe Hinduism, Buddhism, modern Judaism, and hedonism are. I am convinced that Christians have been mistreated for centuries under Islam. I recognize how there are radical Islamic terrorist cells who murder, wage warfare, and plot for the destruction of Jews, Christians, Hindus and others. During a summer in Pakistan, I may have inadvertently met a handful of these, although most Pakistanis and Afghans I met were friendly and hospitable. In the USA, to my knowledge, I haven’t yet met a Muslim who wished for my destruction simply because I was a Christian and an American. In fact, many of them came here out of dissatisfaction with the limitations placed upon their freedoms in the Islamic bloc.

Befriending Your Perceived Enemies

When I ask my fearful Christian Nationalist friends if they have ever befriended a Muslim neighbor, the answers have been predictable:  Never have they invited one over for coffee. They never have dialogued with one in a meaningful way, never visited a mosque. But they all seemed willing to call ICE to investigate if they had heard one of “their” families were living in their neighborhoods. The fearmongering friend I mentioned earlier even defended the crusades, stating how “Christian” warfare resulted in the preservation of “Christianity.” I don’t see that there is much faith involved in a Christianity in which the church violates Christ’s core teachings, such as slaughtering one’s enemies, to preserve and perpetuate its principles.

My young dialogue partner also related that Muslims will pretend to be your friend, as they are trained to do, but deep down inside they are only plotting for your destruction. Yet, unlike many of my other detractors, he was at least acquainted with “โ€ฆa Muslim.” Just one. And he sure wanted to bring that woman to Christ! Realistically, though, there is almost no chance of that happening. If we want to win them, we must befriend them. If you are not willing to believe what they say, but assume your polemical argument is one hundred percent correct, you can never actually trust the person you are trying to “win.” You are plotting to dominate them rather than influence them, while you think that they are plotting your destruction. If you think you can learn about their core beliefs from videos and websites and books, but not from people who are actually the subjects of your studies, you will be a poor confidante, a worse teacher, and by-and-large useless as a Gospel communicator.

Bigotry is Not Faithfulness

To the fearful and uninformed Christians: Quit the fearmongering. Ditch the blatant racism. Stop trying to frame your vitriol as either faithfulness or patriotism. Do as Jesus commanded: Welcome the stranger, and get busy trying to love them as much as you have loved yourself. Your bigotry will not fool believers who have immersed themselves in the Scriptures. If you don’t even understand the basics of the religion you profess, how can you properly evaluate theirs? Stop hating and start practicing the foundational tenets of the faith you aspire to believe in.

* I wholeheartedly believe that what happened to the Branch Davidians in the hands of the FBI was tragic and unspeakably incompetent, regardless of how their leader was living. But that is a separate issue from the reality that David Koresh was abusing underage girls. For those allegations that were later demonstrated to be true, he should have been arrested and tried for his behavior, without the aggression of the ATF and the FBI and the ensuing media circus.


Photo by Alim on Unsplash

About Post Author


Related Essay

>