Christian Nationalism is the fusion of religious beliefs with nationalist sentiments and intersectionality with right-wing movements. Such movements transgress the separation of church and state, promote a sense of exclusivity and entitlement for a single religion–Christianity–and have a negative impact on interfaith dialogue. All areas of public life are affected, including social issues, education, and individual rights. Furthermore, like all modern-day movements, media, and technology play a key role in spreading Christian Nationalist rhetoric and ideology.
Christian Nationalism, in the United States, can trace its roots to colonial days, but religious nationalist movements have arisen across the globe.
As the faithful seek to fuse their deeply-held religious beliefs with their love for country, Christian Nationalism has found fertile ground in the hearts and minds of many. Its significance transcends mere ideology. It impacts policy decisions, electoral outcomes, and the nation’s very identity. In an age marked by increasing polarization, understanding Christian Nationalism is pivotal to comprehending the dynamics of such a society.
Historical Context of Christian Nationalism in America
The origins of Christian Nationalism in the United States can be traced back to when the fledgling nation grappled with the complexities of forging a unique identity.
Many early American settlers emigrated to the new world in pursuit of religious freedom, carrying their faith as a beacon of hope. Some, such as the Pilgrims and Puritans, came with a plan to establish Christian communities that would flourish and spread, with the pastor playing a dual role as mayor. This religious zeal formed the bedrock upon which the American colonies were established. All of the original thirteen states wrote language into their charters that required their statesmen to be followers of God.
The Founding Fathers, men like George Washington, John Adams, and Thomas Jefferson, were certainly influenced by Christian ethics but were also advocates of religious freedom. This duality of belief and liberty culminated in the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, which articulated the principle of the separation of church and state. This amendment, often regarded as a crowning achievement of American democracy, ensured that no particular faith could be imposed as the official religion of the nation.
The evolution of Christian Nationalism did not occur in isolation; it was shaped by historical events and movements that unfolded over the centuries.
The 19th century witnessed the Second Great Awakening, a religious revival movement that swept across the nation. During this period, evangelical Christians gained substantial ground, and their fervor fueled the idea of a morally upright nation guided by Christian values. This period laid some of the groundwork for American Christian Nationalism’s emergence as a potent force.
In the 20th century, with the rise of mass media and televangelism, the fusion of religious and nationalist sentiments gained momentum. Evangelical leaders, with their large followings, began to exert influence on the political landscape, advocating for policies and candidates aligned with their religious beliefs.
Defining Christian Nationalism
Samuel Perry, associate professor at the University of Oklahoma, defines Christian nationalism as “an ideology which seeks to idealize and advocate for a fusion of American civic life with a very particular type of Christianity”. Christianity in this sense, according to his definition, draws a sharp cultural distinction between “the conservative and natural-born citizen” and others.
At the heart of Christian Nationalism lies a foundational belief that the United States is, and always has been, a Christian nation. Christian Nationalists argue that the country’s very identity is intrinsically Christian, a perspective that carries significant implications for its laws, policies, and cultural norms, all rooted in a distinctive religious belief.
This viewpoint posits that the United States was founded upon Christian principles, and its historical documents, such as the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, are seen as divinely inspired, reflecting the will of God’s people.
Christian Nationalism seeks to shape the governance and morality of the nation. Advocates focus on issues related to marriage, family, sexuality, and policies that reflect traditional Christian values.
Christian Nationalists advocate for the public display of religious symbols and practices. They contend that symbols, such as the Ten Commandments, nativity scenes, or crosses, should occupy prominent spaces in public settings as emblematic of the nation’s Christian heritage, emphasizing the centrality of Jesus Christ to their vision of American identity.
Their argument raises complex questions about the separation of church and state. Critics argue that the public display of religious symbols in government buildings and public schools can be interpreted as government endorsement of a particular faith, potentially infringing upon the constitutional principle of religious neutrality.
Political and Social Manifestations of Christian Nationalism
One of the most overt manifestations of Christian Nationalism is in the realm of political rhetoric and campaigns. Politicians, especially those seeking conservative or right-wing support, have increasingly harnessed Christian Nationalist sentiments, often appealing to specific demographics such as white evangelicals, to garner votes and mobilize their base.
Candidates often frame their campaigns within the context of defending and preserving what they perceive as America’s Christian heritage. They invoke religious imagery, quote scripture, and emphasize their Christian faith as a means to connect with Nationalist voters. For many, aligning with Christian Nationalism is seen as a path to political success, becoming a significant aspect of the broader political movement.
This alignment, however, is not without consequences. It can deepen political polarization, as candidates may adopt more extreme positions to appeal to Christian Nationalist constituencies, leaving little room for compromise or moderation. Additionally, it can lead to the perception that religious faith is a litmus test for political office, potentially excluding individuals of other faiths or those who identify as secular from the political process.
Christian Nationalism is bolstered by numerous advocacy groups and organizations that actively promote its ideals. Organizations such as the Family Research Council, Alliance Defending Freedom, and the American Family Association have emerged as influential players in advancing the Christian Nationalist political movement.
These groups, often well-funded and well-connected, exert significant influence on the political landscape. They lobby for policies aligned with Christian Nationalist beliefs, support candidates who share their values, and engage in public awareness campaigns. Their influence extends beyond elections, shaping the broader discourse on issues such as marriage, family, and religious freedom, impacting various facets of American life.
Critics argue that these organizations wield disproportionate power, influencing legislation and policies that may not align with the broader public interest or may infringe upon the rights of marginalized communities. This influence is evident in debates over the public display of religious symbols in government buildings, including the U.S. Capitol.
Intersectionality with Right-Wing Movements
Christian Nationalism and right-wing politics often find common ground on issues related to faith, culture, and social values. This reflects a shared worldview that seeks to defend traditional American values rooted in Christianity.
The relationship between Christian Nationalists and conservative political parties in the United States is symbiotic. Notable political leaders, including former President Donald Trump, have harnessed Christian Nationalist sentiments to garner votes and mobilize their base.
Christian Nationalists offer a dedicated voting bloc and financial support that is motivated by religious values and principles. In return, conservative parties, particularly the Republican Party, provide a platform for the advancement of Christian Nationalist policies and ideals.
However, this partnership is not without its tensions. Some conservatives may be wary of the perceived influence of Christian Nationalism on the party’s image and electability, leading to internal divisions and debates over the extent to which religious values should shape political agendas.
The intersection of Christian Nationalism with right-wing politics exacerbates political polarization. As Christian Nationalist ideals and policies become more deeply embedded in the right-wing agenda, the political center narrows, leaving less room for compromise and cooperation. This polarization can lead to legislative gridlock, making it increasingly challenging to address pressing issues facing the nation.
Furthermore, the influence of Christian Nationalism in right-wing politics can alienate those who do not share these religious beliefs or who advocate for a more secular government. It raises questions about the inclusivity of the political process and the protection of the rights and interests of minority groups.
Critiques and Controversies Surrounding Christian Nationalism
One of the primary concerns surrounding Christian Nationalism revolves around the concept of the separation of church and state. The Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution explicitly prohibits the federal government from establishing or promoting a particular religion. Critics argue that Christian Nationalism, by advocating for the infusion of Christian beliefs into government and public life, poses a direct challenge to this fundamental constitutional principle.
They contend that when religious doctrines influence public policies and legislation, it can lead to government endorsement of a specific faith, placing it in a privileged position. This potentially marginalizes those who adhere to different religions or none at all. The erosion of the separation between church and state raises concerns about the protection of religious freedom, a cornerstone of American democracy.
Critics are also concerned about exclusivity within Christian Nationalism. Critics argue that this political ideology often marginalizes and discriminates against other religious and non-religious minorities, particularly those who do not identify as Christian. In a diverse and multicultural society, embracing an exclusive vision of America as a “Christian nation” can be alienating to those of different faiths or worldviews.
This exclusivity extends to issues like immigration and refugee policies, where some Christian Nationalist groups advocate for preferential treatment of Christian refugees over those of other religions. Such positions have been met with criticism for violating principles of religious equality and humanitarianism.
Interfaith dialogue and religious pluralism are essential elements of a harmonious and inclusive society. Critics argue that Christian Nationalism’s emphasis on the dominance of Christianity can create tension and distrust between religious communities and hinder efforts to foster understanding, mutual respect, and cooperation among various religious groups.
Additionally, the promotion of Christian symbols and practices in public spaces might indicate governmental favor of one faith over others, undermining religious pluralism and diversity. This issue has been the subject of legal battles, with cases reaching the Supreme Court and raising questions about the interpretation of the Establishment Clause.
Christian Nationalism and Social Issues
Christian Nationalist advocates wield considerable influence in shaping policies related to social issues. Advocates oppose such measures as same-sex marriage, non-discrimination protections, and gender-affirming healthcare, and promote “religious freedom bills” which allow businesses and individuals to cite religious objections as a basis for discrimination against LGBTQ+ individuals
Gender and Sexuality
Advocates of Christian Nationalism argue that upholding traditional, heterosexual marriage and opposing transgender rights are essential for preserving what they see as the nation’s Christian identity.
However, critics assert that these policies discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals, infringe upon their civil rights, and contribute to a culture of exclusion and marginalization. The battle over these issues remains a flashpoint in American politics and society.
Similarly, Christian Nationalism plays a significant role in the debate surrounding abortion rights. Advocates often push for stricter regulations and limitations on access to abortion.
Christian Nationalism exerts its influence in the arena of education. It seeks to shape curriculum and teaching materials that reflect Christian Nationalist ideals. This is particularly true in subjects like history and science.
In some instances, Christian Nationalists advocate for the inclusion of creationism or intelligent design in science curricula. They seek to emphasize Christian influences on American history, sometimes downplaying the contributions of non-Christian individuals and communities.
Civil Liberties and Individual Rights
Christian Nationalism’s influence on social issues and education has broader implications for civil liberties and individual rights. Critics argue that policies influenced by Christian Nationalism can infringe upon the freedoms and autonomy of individuals, particularly those in marginalized communities.
For instance, restrictions on LGBTQ+ rights and abortion access are seen as encroachments on personal liberty and privacy. They can also create disparities in access to healthcare and legal protections, disproportionately affecting vulnerable populations.
Intersectionality of White Supremacy and Christian Nationalism
The intersection of white supremacy and Christian nationalism is a complex interplay that intertwines racial ideologies with religious convictions, shaping political rhetoric, social policies, and global dynamics. Politicians align themselves strategically with both ideologies, reinforcing narratives that tie the preservation of a Christian nation to a white cultural and political hegemony. This intersection fosters exclusivity and identity politics, influencing policies that disproportionately impact marginalized communities. It also challenges principles of religious freedom and pluralism, extending its reach globally.
Responses and Counteractions
As Christian Nationalism continues to influence American politics and society, a variety of responses and counteractions have emerged. One of the most noteworthy responses has come from within religious communities themselves. Many Christian and other religious leaders, including evangelical Christian, and faith-based organizations have taken a stand against the fusion of religion and politics. They advocate for a more inclusive and compassionate interpretation of their faith traditions.
These leaders contend that white Christian Nationalism’s exclusionary and divisive rhetoric does not align with Christianity’s fundamental principles of love, compassion, and justice. Consequently, they have actively opposed the politicization of Christianity, both within their congregations and in the public square.
Some religious communities have opened their doors to dialogue and cooperation with individuals from diverse religious backgrounds. These communities recognize the importance of fostering interfaith understanding and unity. In doing so, they counteract the exclusivity associated with Christian Nationalism.
Efforts to promote religious freedom and inclusivity have gained traction as responses to Christian Nationalism. Advocates argue that religious liberty should not be a tool for advancing one faith at the expense of others. Nor should it be used for discriminating against certain groups. Instead, they emphasize the importance of a pluralistic society. A society where all individuals can exercise their religious beliefs, or non-beliefs, without fear of persecution or discrimination.
These efforts encompass legal actions, public awareness campaigns, and educational initiatives. They aim to protect the rights of religious and non-religious minorities, challenge discriminatory policies, and foster a climate of tolerance and respect for diverse worldviews.
Secular organizations have been at the forefront of legal battles to uphold the Establishment Clause and protect religious freedom. They work to ensure that government institutions remain neutral when it comes to matters of faith and religion.
Progressive movements, on the other hand, emphasize inclusivity, diversity, and social justice. They oppose policies that discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals, women’s reproductive rights, and religious or non-religious minorities. All of these have been targets of Christian Nationalist influence.
The Role of Media and Technology
Christian Nationalists often utilize media appearances and interviews to articulate their beliefs. Through these media, they present their vision of America as a Christian nation and garner support for their policy positions. These platforms can be influential in shaping public opinion and mobilizing their base.
Moreover, some media organizations with a Christian Nationalist perspective produce content that reinforces these ideals. These news outlets, radio programs, and publications that align with Christian Nationalist values prioritize stories and perspectives that support their worldview.
Social media, in particular, has been instrumental in connecting like-minded individuals. They foster online communities centered around Christian Nationalist ideals. These platforms enable the sharing of content, the organization of events, and the recruitment of new supporters. This is all done in real-time and on a global scale.
Christian Nationalism Beyond the United States
Christian Nationalism is not a uniquely American phenomenon. In several countries around the world, movements that bear resemblances to American Christian Nationalism have emerged. Movements often center on the idea of preserving a particular religious identity or cultural heritage. They believe this is a foundational aspect of the nation’s identity.
In European nations, some far-right political movements espouse Christian Nationalist ideals. They seek to preserve what they perceive as Christian values and traditions in the face of immigration and cultural change. In India, Hindu Nationalism, often referred to as Hindutva, shares similarities with Christian Nationalism. The emphasis on the dominant religious identity as a defining characteristic of the nation is very similar.
The contexts in which these movements arise can vary significantly. They are often shaped by historical, political, and social factors unique to each country. Exploring these movements offers insights into the diverse ways in which Christian Nationalism or similar ideologies can manifest globally.
A comparative analysis of global manifestations of religious nationalism reveals both commonalities and distinctions. While the specific religious traditions and historical narratives may differ, the underlying theme of preserving a dominant religious identity often remains consistent.
Christian Nationalism, Hindu Nationalism, and other religious nationalist movements share a common desire to assert the primacy of their religious group within the nation. They may advocate for policies that promote their religious beliefs, limit the rights of religious or cultural minorities, or oppose secularism and religious pluralism.
At the same time, the specific historical contexts and interfaith dynamics in each country lead to differences in the ways these ideologies manifest. For example, the history of communal tensions between religious groups in India is distinct from the historical development of religious pluralism in the United States.
The internationalization of Christian Nationalism and similar ideologies can have implications for global geopolitics. As these movements gain momentum and influence, they can shape the foreign policy priorities and alliances of nations.
In the United States, for instance, Christian Nationalism has been particularly associated with the perspectives of some white people, influencing diplomatic relations and international cooperation. Additionally, the promotion of shared values or religious identity can lead to partnerships between nations. While ideological alignment can also potentially strain relations with countries that do not share these values.
Additionally, the spread of religious nationalism can impact international religious freedom. In countries where religious nationalists hold political power, there may be consequences for religious minorities and efforts to promote interfaith dialogue and cooperation.
The Future of Christian Nationalism
The future of Christian Nationalism is subject to multiple variables and uncertainties. Shifting demographics and evolving generational attitudes may influence the appeal and relevance of this ideology. As younger, more diverse generations become a larger portion of the electorate, they may push for more inclusive and progressive policies. This will potentially challenge the dominance of Christian Nationalism in the political sphere.
Currently, the Christian majority is gradually shrinking, and the influence of non-Christian and secular perspectives is growing.
Generational shifts play a role. Younger generations, such as Millennials and Generation Z, tend to be more accepting of diversity and pluralism. They are less likely to embrace exclusionary ideologies, while more likely to advocate for social justice, LGBTQ+ rights, and environmental sustainability.
Christian Nationalism is far from a monolithic or one-dimensional phenomenon. It encompasses a spectrum of beliefs and practices, from a deep religious faith that informs political convictions to extreme, exclusionary ideologies.
The significance of Christian Nationalism lies in its ability to influence policies, elections, and public discourse. It shapes the boundaries of religious freedom and impacts the lives of marginalized communities. Its international reach further underscores its importance on the global stage.
In a time of deepening political divisions and social polarization, it is important to engage critically with ideologies like Christian Nationalism. Reflection on the balance between religious freedom and the separation of church and state, the rights of minorities, and the principles of pluralism and democracy is central.
Religious freedom is concerned with safeguarding the rights and dignity of all individuals regardless of their faith or lack thereof. Religious freedom fosters a society where diverse voices can coexist and contribute to the community.
What do you think? Please share your thoughts below.
Too often, people answer faith questions with dogmatic certitude and neglect the historic diversity and complexity of Christian ideas. The Questions Project is a resource that responds to questions about faith, history, and scripture in a way that honors the historic diversity and complexity of Christian thought. But, this is a work in process and we need your help. Please provide feedback. We are particularly interested in knowing what we have missed and how we can improve our responses. Please keep all comments kind or risk deletion.